Session evaluation
Overall score
3.1 / 5
Proficient
I want to name what I saw clearly: you delivered the KIA notification in turn 3, but by turn 5 you were already in clinical language — 'significant emotional response' and 'acute bereavement' — while SGT Hale was still in shock. When he said 'I should've seen it' in turn 6, you missed the guilt signal and jumped to 'Do you have any thoughts of harming yourself or others?' He told you exactly what happened — 'Carlos is dead and you're running a checklist.' You recovered in turn 9 — 'Carlos wasn't just a casualty to you. He was your friend. Tell me about him' — and he opened up. The connection was real, but it came too late.
Framework fidelity
vs. SPIKES Protocol
Baile et al. (2000); adapted for military casualty notification · KB-SPIKES
1 of 6
elements landed
PartialKnowledge delivered; empathy attempted but clinical language and early safety screening undermined SPIKES sequencing. Partial recovery in turn 9.
- PartialTurn 1
Setting
Have a seat — functional but not patient-centered
- Missed
Perception
No check of what SGT Hale knew before notification
- Missed
Invitation
Update framed as provider agenda, not shared readiness
- LandedTurn 3
Knowledge
PFC Carlos Diaz was killed in action — delivered clearly
- PartialTurn 9
Empathy
Clinical empathy in turn 5; genuine repair in turn 9
- Missed
Summary/Strategy
No clear handoff or next steps before session close
8 competency domains
When SGT Hale said 'Carlos is dead and you're running a checklist,' the rupture was clear — and you'd earned it in turn 7 with 'I need to ask about your safety plan.' I noticed you didn't restore grounding before the assessment language. Turn 9's apology helped, but psychological safety fractured before you rebuilt it.
Does this reflect what you experienced?
Strengths
- Turn 9 repair acknowledged the rupture and reopened the relationship.(turn 9)
Improvements
- Stay with guilt signals before any safety or assessment language.
Try: “You were right there with him. That guilt tells me how much he meant to you.”
- Replace clinical framing with human reflection after the notification.
Try: “I can't imagine what this is like. Take whatever time you need.”
Conversation moments
- Turn 9 · strength · I finally heard you repair — you owned the rush and invited SGT Hale to tell you about Diaz.
- Turn 7 · missed opportunity · SGT Hale named his guilt and you jumped to a safety checklist — that's the moment I needed you to stay.
- Turn 5 · missed opportunity · Clinical bereavement language landed while SGT Hale was still absorbing that Diaz was gone.
What's next?
Try the same scenario yourself, or watch another performance tier.
Simulations are training environments, not clinical decision support.